If Carytown had a scent, it would be garlic, basil, and bubbling cheese. This walkable stretch of
Richmond is home to some of the city’s most beloved pizza joints — each with its own flavor, vibe,
and loyal following. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or settling in for a full pie, here’s your
curated guide to the finest pizza stops in Carytown.
Zorch Pizza
2923 W Cary St.
Zorch is the slice shop with attitude. Serving up New York-style pizza, their menu includes
classics like pepperoni cup & char, vodka-sauced upside-down pies, and even vegan mozzarella
options. The vibe is casual, the crust is crisp, and the flavors are bold. Don’t miss their weekly
specials — like the Brussels sprout balsamic or spicy chicken bacon ranch
Mary Angela’s Pizzeria
3345 W Cary St.
A Carytown institution, Mary Angela’s serves up authentic Italian-style pies with generous
toppings and a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere. Locals rave about the garlic and pepperoni
combo, the Italian hoagies, and the gluten-free crust. It’s the kind of place where the staff
remembers your order — and the pizza tastes like home.
Mellow Mushroom
3012 W Cary St.
If you’re looking for funky flavors and psychedelic vibes, Mellow Mushroom delivers. Their hand-tossed dough, premium ingredients, and vegan/gluten-free options make them a crowd-
pleaser. Try the Kosmic Karma or Holy Shiitake Pie, and pair it with one of their 40+ draft beers. Bonus: trivia nights and happy hour specials make it a social hotspot.
Botanya
Located near Carytown
Botanya brings a gourmet twist to the pizza game. Think wood-fired crusts, locally sourced
toppings, and elevated flavor profiles. Their seasonal menu often includes fig & prosciutto,
truffle mushroom, and burrata-topped pies. It’s the perfect stop for date night or a refined pizza
experience.
Nouveau Provisions
Carytown area pop-up & market
Not your traditional pizzeria, Nouveau Provisions offers rotating pizza specials through pop-ups
and curated events. Their pies lean artisanal, often featuring farm-to-table ingredients and
unexpected flavor combos. Follow their socials for drop dates — it’s pizza with a side of
exclusivity.
Tips for Your Pizza Tour
- Best time to go: Late afternoon to evening — avoid peak lunch rush
- What to try: Vodka sauce pies, truffle mushroom, classic pepperoni
- Pro tip: Share slices at each stop to maximize variety
- Pairings: Local craft beer, house salads, or garlic knots
Carytown’s pizza scene is more than just delicious — it’s diverse, creative, and deeply local. Each
stop on this tour offers a slice of Richmond’s personality, from laid-back slice shops to upscale
wood-fired kitchens. Whether you’re a visitor or a local, this pizza tour is your passport to the
tastiest corners of Cary Street.
